🎧 LISTEN TO THIS ARTICLE ON THE SUBSTACK APP
Picture this: A former CIA officer who now sits in the United States Senate looks her party in the eye and tells them it’s time to lock the permanent bureaucracy in place so that no elected president can ever again fully control the government. That’s exactly what US Senator Elissa Slotkin (D-MI) has been doing.
She isn’t offering ordinary reform. She’s demanding statutes that would turn flexible norms into ironclad law, permanently limiting presidential authority over the agencies. It’s a naked power grab masquerading as institutional protection, and it deserves open contempt.
Slotkin has said the quiet part out loud. She wants an unsexy group of people thinking hard about how to “Trump-proof” the government going forward so that no leader can “do this again.” At the Carnegie Endowment and other forums, she has pressed the same point: Democrats must rebuild what the federal government looks like after Trump by converting informal expectations into binding statutes. Those statutes would carry real legal penalties.
Once on the books, any future president—especially one who challenges the progressive transformative status quo—would find it far harder to direct, reassign, or remove career officials who refuse to carry out his agenda. The bureaucracy would become a permanent, self-protecting elite.
This scheme strikes at the Constitution.
Article II vests the executive power in a single president chosen by the people. The Framers expected that president to run the Executive Branch, not negotiate with an independent corps of experts who answer mainly to themselves. Slotkin’s plan would carve that power away by statute. It would treat the administrative state as the rightful owner of its authority rather than holding it in trust from the elected executive.
That is the opposite of the limited, accountable government the Constitution established. It revives the Progressive idea, associated with Woodrow Wilson, that administrative questions aren’t political questions and that experts should be insulated from elections.
The Separation of Powers takes a direct hit. Congress makes the laws. The President executes them. The courts decide disputes. For decades, the administrative state has blurred those lines by writing rules that act like laws, enforcing them, and judging challenges. Codifying the bureaucracy’s independence finishes the job. Unelected officials would gain stronger legal cover to ignore or slow-walk the policy choices of a president the voters just elected.
We have already seen the pattern: the Russia collusion narrative built on thin evidence, career staff resisting Title IX reforms, formal dissent cables opposing lawful Executive Orders, and internal memos on how to delay presidential directives. Slotkin wants those tactics enshrined in statute rather than left as informal resistance.
Representative government is the biggest casualty. When you vote for a president, you are choosing a direction. If statutes freeze the permanent staff in place and shield them from ordinary presidential control, your vote matters less. A Republican president inherits a bureaucracy trained to resist. A Democrat president inherits one that moves in lockstep. Progressive priorities become the default that survives every election. That’s not how a republic is supposed to work. The people are supposed to change course through the officials they choose. Slotkin’s approach turns elections into theater while actual power remains with the permanent class that never answers to the voters.
Look at the practical effect. Once those statutes exist, a president who tries to restore traditional Title IX protections or enforce immigration laws would face legal roadblocks. Career officials could cite the new laws as a reason to refuse direction or outlast the administration. Slotkin’s plan would give institutions statutory armor.
Her own record lays bare the motive.
Slotkin is a former CIA officer who joined the lawmakers who urged military personnel to refuse orders they decided were illegal. She has spoken openly about using investigations and prosecutions against people who worked for the current administration, specifically to deter young conservatives from taking those jobs. An official with that background and that track record is now arguing for laws that would make the Deep State bureaucracy harder for any future president to manage. That’s not neutral institutional design. It’s an axe to grind written into the statute books.
The Framers never intended the Executive Branch to be run by experts immune to the ballot box. They gave the president the duty to ensure that the laws are faithfully executed and expected elections to matter. Slotkin’s proposal rejects that design. That’s why the contempt is warranted.
Giving left-wing, totalitarian ex-CIA officials with an axe to grind against the Constitution and the sitting President the majority in Congress this past midterm election is shaping up to be a direct threat to the survival of our Republic. The administrative state already operates with too little democratic control. Slotkin’s proposal would entrench that arrangement so deeply that reversing it becomes nearly impossible.
Americans who still believe the Constitution means what it says need to treat this as the danger it is: a deliberate attempt to replace accountable executive authority with permanent bureaucratic rule.
It’s insurrection. And it’s her second attempt.









